Product Flops

    Amazon Wrote Off $170 Million on the Fire Phone

    Weeks after launch the price fell from $199 to 99 cents. Bezos called it what it was: an experiment.

    Amazon•2014•4 min read
    Collage: Jeff Bezos holding up a smartphone with arrows pointing at it, next to a pile of boxes
    Illustration: FailForward

    The Failure

    Amazon's Fire Phone was a spectacular failure, resulting in a $170 million write-down and about $83 million of unsold phone inventory.

    The lesson

    Embrace failure as part of the innovation process. Test, learn, and pivot quickly.

    In June 2014, Jeff Bezos walked onto a Seattle stage and pulled a phone out of his pocket. It was the reveal of one of Amazon's worst-kept secrets: after years of development at its Lab126 hardware division, the company that sold everything was finally selling a smartphone.

    And not a modest one. Bezos had personally shaped the Fire Phone around two showpiece features. Dynamic Perspective used four infrared cameras to track the user's head and shift the interface in fake 3D as you moved. Firefly could point the camera at almost any object, song or show and recognize it — and, naturally, offer to buy it on Amazon.

    “If you're going to take bold bets, they're going to be experiments. A few big successes compensate for dozens and dozens of things that didn't work.”

    Jeff Bezos

    The skeptics' question was simple: why would anyone pay iPhone money — $199 on a two-year contract, locked to AT&T — for Amazon's first phone? Fire OS, Amazon's fork of Android, shipped without Google's apps: no Google Maps, no Gmail, no YouTube. The 3D trick was clever, but nobody could quite explain what it was for.

    The market answered the question within weeks of the July 25 launch. Reviews called the signature features gimmicks that drained the battery; buyers stayed away in droves. Six weeks in, the price was cut from $199 to 99 cents. When it reported that quarter's results in October, Amazon took a $170 million write-down largely tied to the phone and admitted to about $83 million of Fire Phone inventory still left over. By 2015 the Fire Phone was dead.

    What happened next inside Amazon is the actual story. Nobody was fired over the flop. Bezos told Ian Freed, the executive who ran the project, not to lose a minute of sleep over it. The company's public posture wasn't damage control but doctrine: big companies must run experiments big enough to hurt, or they stop inventing.

    Out of the Fire Phone wreckage came Echo and Alexa — built largely by the same hardware team.
    Out of the Fire Phone wreckage came Echo and Alexa — built largely by the same hardware team.

    "If you think that's a big failure, we're working on much bigger failures right now," Bezos said two years later — cheerfully. In his letters to shareholders he formalized the point: as a company grows, the size of its failed experiments has to grow with it, or the experiments aren't moving the needle.

    And the Fire Phone's team and technology didn't evaporate. Lab126 rolled much of that talent and hardware learning straight into a strange little cylinder that shipped quietly a few months later: the Echo, with a voice assistant called Alexa. The category-defining product Amazon actually owned — voice computing — came from the wreckage of the one it didn't.

    The Fire Phone remains one of the most expensive product flops of its decade, and one of the most instructive: the company metabolized a nine-figure failure into its next platform, on purpose, in public.

    Questions

    Why did the Fire Phone fail?

    Amazon's Fire Phone asked for iPhone money, $199 on a two-year AT&T contract, but shipped without Google's apps such as Google Maps, Gmail and YouTube, and reviews called its 3D and Firefly features gimmicks that drained the battery.

    How much did Amazon lose on the Fire Phone?

    Amazon wrote off $170 million, largely tied to the Fire Phone, and admitted to $83 million of unsold inventory. Six weeks after the July 25 launch, the phone's price had been cut from $199 to 99 cents.

    What did Amazon build after the Fire Phone?

    The Echo, with the voice assistant Alexa: Amazon's Lab126 rolled much of the Fire Phone team's talent and hardware learning into it. Nobody was fired, and Jeff Bezos told project head Ian Freed not to lose a minute of sleep over the flop.

    More Product Flops

    All stories →